Viral post on low-paid watchman rekindles debate on poverty and parenthood, Internet divided

What began as a seemingly ordinary social media observation quickly spiralled into a heated online debate, after a post about a low-paid watchman welcoming his third child triggered sharp reactions across the internet. The viral post, which described a 25-year-old watchman earning less than Rs 10,000 a month, reignited discussions on poverty, fair wages, family planning, and India’s shifting demographics. While the authenticity of the incident could not be independently verified, it drew thousands of responses on X, deeply polarising 

The user described him as “burdened” with supporting five lives at an age when many are just beginning their careers, calling attention to cycles of poverty and lack of access to policy awareness.

Questions Over Wages and Responsibility

Several users shifted the focus to the watchman’s income, questioning why someone working two jobs earns so little. Many argued that employers should ensure fair pay, pointing out that similar struggles are faced by watchmen, drivers, and other informal workers across the country.

Supporters Defend Parenthood

Others defended the watchman, arguing that having more children helps stabilise India’s total fertility rate. Some users suggested that children provide emotional strength to parents and criticised the idea of viewing parenthood purely as a financial burden.

Policy Gaps and Awareness

The debate also highlighted gaps in family planning awareness, with users claiming that government policies may not be reaching the most vulnerable sections of society. The viral post has evolved into a broader conversation on wages, social responsibility, fertility trends and policy outreach, reflecting deep divisions over how India balances economic hardship with personal choices in a changing society.