MS Dhoni - A strength or a liability for CSK in IPL 2025?

Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) made history on Friday by securing their first victory over Chennai Super Kings (CSK) at Chepauk in 17 years in IPL 2025. Meanwhile, the 50-run defeat for CSK has reignited debates over MS Dhoni's role in the team and his decision-making on the field.

A Historic Win for RCB, A Wake-Up Call for CSK

Batting first, RCB posted an impressive 196/7 in 20 overs, with skipper Rajat Patidar scoring 51 off 32 balls. CSK, in response, struggled to build momentum and managed only 146/8.

While Dhoni entertained fans with a quick-fire 30, not out off 16 balls, it was too little, too late, as CSK failed to chase the target. Former cricketers have begun questioning Dhoni's choices, particularly his decision to bat at number nine, a move that left many baffled. 

Shane Watson, former Australia all-rounder, criticized CSK's tactics, questioning why Dhoni, still a powerful striker, continues to demote himself in the order when his experience could be crucial.

The Dhoni Obsession: A Strength or a Liability?

Dhoni remains a cult figure for CSK supporters, but his prominence is now raising concerns about the franchise's long-term future.

Ambati Rayudu, former CSK batter, pointed out that many fans are Dhoni loyalists first, often cheering when other batters get out just to see their icon walk in. Further, he suggested that this intense ‘obsession’ may be detrimental to CSK as they transition beyond the Dhoni era.

Rayudu also emphasized the need for Dhoni himself to address this culture, urging him to encourage fans to support the entire team rather than just him. As CSK faces mounting challenges, their over-reliance on Dhoni’s presence, both on and off the field, could impact the franchise's adaptability in the future.

What Lies Ahead for CSK and Dhoni?

While Dhoni's wicketkeeping reflexes and batting bursts continue to impress, his influence as a leader is under scrutiny.

Criticism from former cricketers like Virender Sehwag, who dismissed Dhoni's 0.16-second stumping as routine, highlights the growing debate about whether his star power is enough to keep CSK competitive.