IPL 2025: MS Dhoni’s time to retire is already gone; critics slam veteran amid CSK’s continued poor form

Chennai Super Kings (CSK) captain MS Dhoni, once hailed as the undisputed ‘Captain Cool,’ now faces mounting criticism for his prolonged stint in the IPL amid the team’s dismal performance this season.

With CSK losing three consecutive matches, including a baffling chase against Delhi Capitals on April 5, critics argue that Dhoni’s refusal to retire is tarnishing his legacy.

Retire Before Respect Slips Away: Tiwary’s Scathing Take

Former India batter and MSD’s ex-teammate Manoj Tiwary minced no words, stating Dhoni “should have retired after IPL 2023” when he led CSK to their fifth title. “The fame, name, and respect he earned are slipping away with his current performances. Fans can’t bear watching him like this,” Tiwary said on Cricbuzz.

Dhoni, batting at No. 7, scored 30* off 26 balls in the loss to Delhi, leaving fans frustrated as CSK fell short by 27 runs. In four matches this season, he has managed just 76 runs, sparking debates over his role.

Tiwary further highlighted the public backlash stating “After the last match, the way fans came out on the roads and gave interviews against him, it should have been a sign that it's not working anymore.”

ALSO READ: CSK coach Stephen Fleming breaks silence on Dhoni's retirement speculation, says...

Fitness vs. Performance: The Knee Controversy

CSK coach Stephen Fleming’s claim that Dhoni “can’t run for more than 10 overs” drew skepticism. Dhoni’s strike rate (140) and average (76) this season mask a grim reality that his runs haven’t translated into wins.

Against Rajasthan Royals, he and Vijay Shankar scored 82 runs in nine overs without a single dismissal, relying on singles despite needing 108. “They shut shop too early,” said ex-India batter Wasim Jaffer.

Top-Order Collapse Exposes CSK’s Fragility

Former South Africa coach Mark Boucher pinned blame on CSK’s faltering top order. He noted that Dhoni and Jadeja are walking in by the 10th over and this lower order can’t fix top-order failures every time, he told ESPNCricinfo. CSK’s inability to chase 180+ targets since 2019 has worsened, with their batting lineup crumbling under pressure.

Fan Sentiment: From Devotion to Disillusionment

Chennai’s loyal fanbase, known for chanting “Dhoni! Dhoni!” even in losses, now voices dissent. Social media trends like #DhoniRetire and viral videos of fans criticizing his approach highlight eroding trust.

ALSO READ: Happy Retirement Thala Trends on X After Dhoni's parents attend CSK VS DC match

What’s Next for CSK?

CSK faces Punjab Kings in Mullanpur on April 8. With playoffs slipping away, the pressure mounts on Dhoni to either reinvent his role or step aside. As Tiwary warned, “A strong call needs to be made. If it’s not working, let it go.”

Key Stats:

• Dhoni in IPL 2025: 76 runs, 140 strike rate, 76 average (4 matches).
• CSK’s last 3 matches: Lost to DC, RR, and KKR.
• Last successful 180+ chase: 2019 season.