TV
Early test screenings for James Gunn’s Superman have sparked conflicting reports, raising questions about the DC Universe’s (DCU) reboot ahead of its July 11, 2025, release. Insiders describe reactions as everything from ‘terrible’ to ‘tremendously good,’ leaving fans uncertain about the film’s trajectory after Warner Bros.’ recent DCEU setbacks.
Behind the Test Screenings
Outlets like ComicBookMovie and The Direct have stated their sources claiming contradictory reviews. As per one, the latest cuts show improvement, with praise for Nicholas Hoult’s Lex Luthor, upgraded visual effects, and Rachel Brosnahan’s ‘funny, adorable’ Lois Lane. Further, the tone reportedly blends humour and emotion, akin to Wonder Woman and Guardians of the Galaxy.
Additionally, David Corenswet’s Superman drew comparisons to Brandon Routh’s 2006 portrayal, while surprise villains and sci-fi elements reportedly added intrigue. However, scepticism came with The Direct quoting Insider Jeff Sneider initially noting optimism but later citing a trusted source calling the film ‘terrible,’ though specifics remain unclear.
James Gunn’s Adjustments
Director James Gunn confirmed screenings are guiding minor edits and potential reshoots for ‘tiny’ additions, like action tweaks. He emphasized these changes aren’t major, reflecting his evolving approach to post-production polish.
Why Skepticism Persists
Past superhero films, like The Flash and Ant-Man 3, drew early praise but flopped upon release. Gunn’s track record (Guardians of the Galaxy, The Suicide Squad) offers hope, yet test screenings—often of unfinished cuts—are unreliable. Campea stressed that incomplete visuals and temp scores skew reactions, urging patience until final reviews emerge.
Stakes for DCU
With Warner Bros. banking on Superman to revive its superhero slate after five DCEU flops, the film introduces key DCU figures: Isabel Merced’s Hawkgirl, Nathan Fillion’s Green Lantern, and Milly Alcock’s Supergirl and their success could pivot the franchise’s future.
As Gunn fine-tunes the project, definitive judgment awaits June 2025 critic screenings. For now, the mixed buzz underscores both anticipation and caution for DC’s high-stakes reboot.
